Navigating the Mind's Maze
A journey through the cognitive traps of investing in Thomas’ mind—Pt. One
Investing isn’t just a game of numbers—by far. It’s a deeply human endeavor.
Every decision is influenced by a web of thoughts, emotions, and biases—some helpful, some disastrous. Imagine the financial markets as a vast, intricate tapestry, where each thread is a choice, a moment of insight, or, often, also a misstep.
Today, I’ll explore five cognitive biases through the story of an investor, which we’ll call Thomas 😉—biases that shape, distort, and sometimes derail even the best intentions.
But Thomas isn’t just an investor; he’s all of us.
His journey through the markets reflects the inner battles we face when emotions collide with logic, and when optimism clashes with reality.
The Echo Chamber
Thomas loved tech stocks. He didn’t care that many companies were still unprofitable—to him, the sector was inevitable. Every article he read, every conversation he had, seemed to reinforce his belief in its unstoppable growth.
This was no coincidence. Thomas had fallen into the echo chamber of confirmation bias, seeking out information that aligned with his views and filtering out anything that didn’t.
At first, his strategy seemed to work. He subscribed to tech-focused newsletters, joined bullish forums, and consumed endless content about the sector’s potential. But in doing so, he ignored warnings about overvaluation and regulatory risks.
His portfolio became a one-dimensional bet, vulnerable to the whims of a single industry.
When the cracks in tech began to show, Thomas wasn’t ready. He dismissed criticism as noise, doubling down instead of reassessing. His belief in his narrative had become so strong that it overshadowed the reality of market dynamics.
It wasn’t just his portfolio that was at risk—it was his ability to adapt. Even worse, this inability was continously enhanced by poor habits as a result of this bias.
A Paralyzing Grip
And of course then came the fall.
A few of Thomas’ cherished tech stocks started to slide, and the pain of seeing red in his portfolio was sharper than he ever anticipated. It wasn’t just the financial loss—it was the emotional weight of being ‘wrong.’
So, he clung to those stocks, waiting for a rebound that might never come.
This is the cruel logic of loss aversion: the fear of losing something often outweighs the desire to gain.
For Thomas, this meant holding onto underperforming assets long past their expiration date. He convinced himself that selling would lock in failure, even as better opportunities passed him by.
Every day, he watched his positions sink further, yet he couldn’t bring himself to let go. His inaction wasn’t strategic; it was emotional. The pain of realizing a loss—twice as powerful as the joy of a gain—kept him paralyzed, anchored to stocks that no longer made sense.
‘Perhaps This Game is Not That Difficult’
But not all of Thomas’ decisions were driven by fear. Some were fueled by an entirely different beast.
Buoyed by a few early successes, Thomas began to believe he had cracked the code. He traded more frequently, took bigger risks, and started trusting his gut more than his research.
This newfound bravado blinded him to the randomness of markets. What he experienced to be skill was often just luck, and what he dismissed as caution was wisdom he should have heeded.
His portfolio, once carefully balanced, became a playground for high-risk gambles.
Thomas’ overconfidence led to tunnel vision. He dismissed diversification as unnecessary and underestimated the market’s ability to humble even the savviest investor.
The volatility he once embraced began to chip away at his gains, turning what should have been a lesson in humility into a cautionary tale.
Chained to the Past
Even as the market shifted, Thomas couldn’t let go of the past. He was anchored to the prices he had paid for his stocks and the heights they had once reached. These numbers, irrelevant to the present, became his benchmarks for success.
When a stock dipped below his purchase price, he refused to sell, waiting for it to recover. When it soared to an all-time high, he held on, convinced it would go higher still.
This fixation on historical numbers blinded him to the current reality—one where market conditions and company fundamentals had changed.
Anchoring bias turned Thomas into his own worst enemy. He wasn’t making decisions based on the future; he was chasing the past.
Every time he held onto a sinking stock or missed a better opportunity, he was reminded that the market doesn’t care about where you’ve been—it only cares about where you’re going.
The Illusion of Collective Wisdom
Finally, Thomas succumbed to one of the oldest traps in the book.
His mistakes had turned overconfidence into insecurity. And seeing that underperformance gap grow pushed him farther away from doing his own work without caring much about others.
When he saw others piling into a trending stock, he jumped in too. Without doing much work. It felt safe(r)—he was wrong before, and something needed to change.
But markets have a way of punishing herd behavior, nowadays often called FOMO.
By the time Thomas bought in, prices had already been inflated by the rush. And when the it burst, he found himself scrambling to sell, caught in the same selling force that had gripped everyone else.
In the end, the worst part wasn’t even the financial loss; it was the realization that he hadn’t made his own decision. He had let the noise of the crowd drown out his own analysis. What felt like collective wisdom was often just collective folly, driven by fear, greed, and the human need to belong.
It’s All of Us
Thomas’ journey isn’t unique—it’s the story of every investor at some point.
These biases—confirmation bias, loss aversion, overconfidence, anchoring, and herd behavior—aren’t just quirks of the mind. They’re deeply ingrained tendencies that shape how we navigate uncertainty.
But recognizing them is the first step toward overcoming them.
For Thomas, that meant stepping back from the noise, reevaluating his process, and learning to question his instincts. It wasn’t about becoming emotionless; it was about becoming self-aware.
Challenge your beliefs. Seek out opposing views, even when it’s uncomfortable.
Embrace losses as part of the game. Selling isn’t failure; it’s strategy.
Stay humble. The market doesn’t owe you anything, and luck plays a bigger role than we like to admit.
Let go of the past. Anchors weigh you down more than they guide you.
Think for yourself. Crowds are noisy, and their wisdom is fleeting.
Remember: we’ve all been here.
Investing, like life, is messy. It’s filled with uncertainty, mistakes, and surprises.
But it’s also a process—a journey of learning, adapting, and growing.
And if Thomas’ story teaches us anything, it’s that the real key to success isn’t avoiding bias entirely. It’s understanding it, managing it, and finding clarity amid the chaos.
If you appreciate this contribution, please like and share by hitting the button below 👉